So the latest eBay buzz has been about eBay’s new neighborhoods. Apparently, the answer to some of the stagnancy on eBay will revolve around social networking. The belief is that the more buyers and sellers network on eBay, the longer they will spend on eBay’s site, which hopefully will translate into more shopping time. Perhaps a Star Wars fan club’s exchanges will go a long way in promoting more sales.
It’s certainly not far fetched. For example, there are many clubs out there, such as a Porsche fan club, or a Nike fan club, where members buy and sell each other’s things on the buy/sell string. In fact, some people prefer to buy and sell within the fan club because they have a greater sense of trust for long standing members in the community. Members in the fan club can be much more helpful with questions, such as with the types of items being sold, for example, whether or not a certain car part from a 2001 model would fit the same car that was made in a different year. Lastly, members in a club are far less concerned about margins, which of course is better for the consumer.
I applaud eBay’s effort and creativity, but really, I’m not absolutely convinced this will be as successful as they hope it’ll be. Are any of you sold on eBay's Neighborhoods? I have a couple of reasons to support my pessimism.
1. Communities will get very little involvement, especially from large sellers:
Larger sellers, who are frequently busy, will find it hard pressed to actively participate in a community. With so much to do, many sellers would rather opt for lower involvement over a higher level of involvement. A quick look today at communites gives all the evidence you need. Many of the communities are empty of members and of posts. The Michael Jordan community has 25 members, and only 1 post. Compare that number to the thousands of posts in October in the Air Jordan shoes forum on Niketalk.com (not affiliated with Nike). Even the red hot iPhone community only has a mere 220 members and 40 posts.
2. Buyers don’t trust eBay as much as they trust fan forums:
The main purpose of eBay is to sell or buy goods, whereas the main purpose of fan clubs is to exchange input and thoughts on a subject matter that you have a great appreciation for. Buying and selling are tertiary points to the club. I compare it to the difference between walking into a shoe store at a mall and asking a sales person which pair of basketball shoes would perform the best for me versus asking members in a Nike fan club/community.
The sales person would likely point out their most expensive pair of shoes as the best performing shoe, while the fan club’s response would be more around their best and worse experiences with the shoes that have been suggested. Again, referring back to the Michael Jordan community, the lone post on there, titled "New Product at http://stores.ebay.com/Solestop-com" is an attempt to sell you something. Not appealing at all to a fan like myself.
On a completely seperate note, I received my credit from Apple for my iPhone. Now…what to do with it? I’m thinking perhaps a Bluetooth for my iPhone? I'm open to any of your suggestions! Initally, I was going to get one of the new cases and a screen protector. However, since I bought the accidental protection warranty from SquareTrade, I’m much less worried about protecting the phone. I really love not having to worry about it all the time.
Which also reminds me…Rus’ blog has a great write-up for consumers on the differences between a SquareTrade warranty, and the typical phone insurance plan that cell phone providers like Verizon offers you. Take it from someone who has done the homework, a SquareTrade warranty is hands down a much better investment (no, I’m not just being bias) unless you are the type of person who is prone to losing your phone. It’s certainly a great read for anyone who just spent $300 or more on a brand new phone and is considering getting cellphone insurance. I for one am glad that I chose an iPhone warranty over iPhone insurance.